Ratings

 Rambit


战队: 标准会员
加入日期: 24 June 2007
帖子:3609
发布24 October 2011 - 9:39 pm
Personally I am at a point where I am considering removing CS ratings even with the knowledge that the majority of people want them. I think they turn regular players into point obsessed lunatics and they are like a drug that many people are addicted to. Perhaps I need to remove them so people can kick the addiction instead of being point junkies.

Or am I wrong?
链接 | 回复 | 引用
 Direwolf_


战队: 标准会员
加入日期: 10 December 2008
帖子:25
发布24 October 2011 - 9:58 pm
how would you remove ratings but keep the game stats/recs?
I like being able to view the stats in euro games.
链接 | 回复 | 引用
 Ubiquitous


战队: 标准会员
加入日期: 20 July 2008
帖子:198
编辑24 October 2011 - 10:14 pm通过Ubiquitous
Keep ratings for CBA (remove the CBA ladder though)
We need ratings in CBA so we can play against other players of similar skill level.
Ratings are useless on the other ladders, they are not competitive like they were designed to be, they only serve the purpose of people trying to get highest rating possible.
Keep match links, I enjoy watching recs.
链接 | 回复 | 引用
 [ViCiouS]____Tom____


战队: 标准会员
加入日期: 24 July 2007
帖子:1716
发布24 October 2011 - 10:37 pm
Remove the ratings entirely.
链接 | 回复 | 引用
 Woof_woof


战队: 标准会员
加入日期: 16 June 2011
帖子:2770
发布24 October 2011 - 10:41 pm
dont remove ratings
链接 | 回复 | 引用
 _LC_Mau5_RTK


战队: 标准会员
加入日期: 22 September 2009
帖子:3635
发布24 October 2011 - 10:45 pm
Remove ratings.
- Keep match links/ Wins/losses/ recorded games/ match detail things.


Im pretty sure I speak on the behalf of 90% of all blood players
(Vicious/LC/EoT/ ) etc.
About


The only problem is if you make CBA the only rated ladder, thats ALL anyone would play.
链接 | 回复 | 引用
 lbr0nc0l


战队: 标准会员
加入日期: 27 August 2011
帖子:18
发布24 October 2011 - 11:08 pm
Remove the ratings.
链接 | 回复 | 引用
 Ruby_Weapon_4


战队: 标准会员
加入日期: 8 November 2007
帖子:35
发布24 October 2011 - 11:18 pm
I might kill if I can't get my points!!! lol. I'd hate to meet the guy that's that obsessed about his rate. Reminds me of all the people in the RM rooms that don't allow zero gamers to play.

Would you still have the required rating feature for entering rooms? Kind of essential to get a quality game going.

I suggest making them invisible unless you view that persons profile. Kinda the middle road I guess but I think people might get mad if you completely remove them. Could just do a trial period and see what happens. Although maybe if people didn't have rates anymore they'd be willing to try new scenarios. Changed my mind. Get rid of them completely.
链接 | 回复 | 引用
 [ iF ]Salvador__


战队: 标准会员
加入日期: 29 March 2011
帖子:187
发布24 October 2011 - 11:56 pm
Do not remove them, it will ruin the gameplay and it's development.. New strategies on each scenario have been found due to the existence of ratings (or atleast motivated by them). Ratings makes the game competitive and that's what makes aoe move forward.

For instance, in mini castle blood games when somebody loses their hero most people will immediatly resign because that already happens sometimes even though we're "point junkies", just imagine what will happen if ratings are removed, lots of quitters because it won't really matter..

Please keep them.
链接 | 回复 | 引用
 [ xHEROx ]_Vinotinto_


战队: 标准会员
加入日期: 16 January 2011
帖子:373
发布25 October 2011 - 12:07 am
1 , remove
链接 | 回复 | 引用
 [Berry]Appleberry


战队: 标准会员
加入日期: 10 April 2011
帖子:42
发布25 October 2011 - 12:15 am
I don't understand why many people get so annoyed by ratings... ;bored I think you should not removed them since a lot of people would complain a lot about it, besides this thread is in english and a lot of people don't know what you are discussing right now :S
链接 | 回复 | 引用
 SalvadorAllende


战队: 标准会员
加入日期: 30 July 2010
帖子:31
发布25 October 2011 - 12:24 am
1, Remove, If ur 17++ or more at CBA it cuz u won it with skills, or hacking, making the game crash, OOS, if u say no, then u r a hypocrite. If u remove i think we can have games just for fun, like CS must be. Like we enjoy playing TTF, Jurassic Park and TTD 3. when i play CBA and one "high pro rated player" is about to lose the game always crashes, lol, weird uh? maybe then we can have a community with skills guys at CBA and other scenarios that enjoy playing, and not stupid ppl wanting more and more point for wut? respect? being cool? feeling that ur better cuz ur CS Overral shows 2.k?. i totally support this idea.
链接 | 回复 | 引用
 CaCha


战队: 黄金会员
加入日期: 6 April 2008
帖子:1080
发布25 October 2011 - 12:35 am
I have a simple answer for u if u remove raiting system u will kill voobly, i am 100 % agree about potns yunkies, but raiting is part of game on AOC, when u make multi ladder system u already kill RPG´S UDPS and no rated maps, points is the reaason why a lot of players keep playing this game, points make ppl to be more commited on a game, if voobly has not point as soon as players (im talking about cba) see they had bad civis they will quit, so the game will stop being funny, now with reated if u had a bad civi at least u figth to win points
链接 | 回复 | 引用
 [Eot_]Master_G


战队: 标准会员
加入日期: 10 January 2008
帖子:4477
发布25 October 2011 - 12:37 am
Didn't we already try this and it ended up backfiring more then helping?
链接 | 回复 | 引用
 Rambit


战队: 标准会员
加入日期: 24 June 2007
帖子:3609
发布25 October 2011 - 12:51 am
Quote:
how would you remove ratings but keep the game stats/recs?
I like being able to view the stats in euro games.
Quote:
Remove ratings.
- Keep match links/ Wins/losses/ recorded games/ match detail things.
Yes, that would be what we would do. We are already looking into a non-rated ladder to go with the current ladders so would be easy enough to do.
Quote:
Do not remove them, it will ruin the gameplay and it's development.. New strategies on each scenario have been found due to the existence of ratings (or atleast motivated by them). Ratings makes the game competitive and that's what makes aoe move forward.

For instance, in mini castle blood games when somebody loses their hero most people will immediatly resign because that already happens sometimes even though we're "point junkies", just imagine what will happen if ratings are removed, lots of quitters because it won't really matter..

Please keep them.
Personally I don't understand why people need to get points in order to play a game (or not quit early). Well I understand why they quit early, but I don't understand why they find in enjoyable if the only difference is a somewhat meaningless number next to their name slightly increasing.
Quote:
Didn't we already try this and it ended up backfiring more then helping?
I don't recall a full removal of CS ratings. We have tried many things but not a full removal AFAIK, definitely not for a long period of time. IMO the longer you leave it the less of an issue it will seem as people will eventually forget.


链接 | 回复 | 引用
[1]23456789101112131415161718192021»
从 1 15中展现404 - 0
讨论区跳转: